Lifetime ISA (LISA) the new pension?

Retirment planningAfter last year’s budget and the pre-budget talk of reducing tax relief on pensions, the government introduced “bonuses” on ISAs. In the form of Lifetime ISAs. But what is a LISA? And how does a LISA compare to a pension? Is the LISA the new pension? This article explores the question Should I invest in a LISA or a Pension?

What is a LISA?                     

  • You can save up to £4,000 a year into a LISA
  • At the end of the tax year the government will add a 25% bonus to the LISA based on contributions in that tax year e.g., if you save £1,000 you’ll receive a £250 bonus, if you save the full £4,000 you’ll receive a £1,000 bonus
  • Bonuses are paid from age 18 to 50
  • Anyone aged over 18 and under 40 can open an account
  • The £4,000 will be counted against the annual ISA savings allowance – £20,000 (as at 2022/23 tax year). If fully subscribing, the remaining £16,000 will not receive bonuses
  • The Lifetime ISA is designed for two specific purposes:
    • for first-time buyers to use towards a residential property
    • To take out and use in retirement after age 60 

Using the LISA to save for retirement

The LISA can be accessed from age 60

  • It doesn’t have to be taken all at once and partial withdrawals can be taken
  • Withdrawals from a LISA are all tax-free

There are penalties if the money is taken before 60 and is not used to purchase a first home: 

  • the government bonuses will be lost along with any interest that these have accrued
  • There will be a 5% penalty on the amount withdrawn

It’s a horrible circumstance, but there is a provision in the Lifetime ISA rules that allows you to access the cash as a tax-free lump sum if you’re terminally ill, provided that you have 12 months or less to live.

If you die, and you’re married or have a civil partner, your Lifetime ISA allowance passes to him/her to invest your Lifetime ISA savings as well as their own. This is on top of their usual ISA allowances. However, the funds in the Lifetime ISA do form part of the estate for inheritance tax purposes.

Pensions Vs LISA 

So, how does a LISA compare to a pension:

  • Auto Enrolment means for the employed, employers have to make minimum contributions into a pension on employees’ behalf. They don’t have to do so into a LISA.
  • Higher-rate taxpayers get tax relief at 40% on contributions into a pension
  • LISAs can affect your benefit entitlement whereas pensions do not
  • Money can be taken from a pension from age 55 (rising to 57 in 2028); the minimum age is 60 to withdraw from a LISA without penalty.
  • Money invested in a pension is outside of the estate for inheritance tax (IHT) purposes whereas money within a LISA will form part of an individual’s IHT allowance (the IHT threshold is currently £325,000)
  • 100% of your earned income or £40,000 per annum (whichever is lower) can be paid into a pension each year and receive tax relief (there are certain exceptions to this for more information, click here.
  • Business owners can make payments into their pensions as a business expense – they cannot into LISAs
  • On bankruptcy, Pensions cannot be taken to pay creditors whereas ISAs can
  • Tax relief is applied to pension contributions immediately whereas with an LISA, the bonus is not received until the end of the tax year
  • Pension contributions paid via salary sacrifice into an employer scheme, are not be subject to national insurance this is not the case with a LISA


  • On taking money out of a pension, 25% of it is tax-free– the rest is taxed as income. Money can be withdrawn entirely tax-free from a LISA. Having said that, the tax rates on pensions, encourage individuals to take it as income so that they do not breech tax bands thus providing retirement income
  • The LISA is more flexible with the option to withdraw the money before age 60 (with penalties) but again will this mean that individuals may not make adequate retirement provisions if they are tempted to withdraw their money before age 60 ?
  • Apart from with critical illness and death money cannot be withdrawn from a pension early, but if prepared to pay a 5% penalty money can withdrawn from a LISA.

So, is this the start of a new pensions ISA?  Is the LISA the new way to plan for retirement? Should I invest in a LISA or a Pension? It could form part of your plan and it’s a good idea to have a plan for retirement!

If you would like to meet for a complimentary initial meeting to plan for your retirement, please contact me.

The information contained within this document is correct as at 2022/23 tax year and is based on current government legislation. This can change. Tax rules, rates and allowances are all subject to change and are dependent on individual circumstances. The Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate tax advice and some forms of offshore investments. The value of investments and the income from them can fall as well as rise and you may not get back the full amount you invested.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *